Movie Review: "A Penitent Thief" - A Powerful Call for Criminal Justice Reform

On Sunday, March 9, 2025, an exclusive private screening of A Penitent Thief took place at the Shaquille O’Neal Theater in Newark, New Jersey. Hosted by Milton Studios and directed by Ben Harmatz, this groundbreaking documentary captivated an audience of high-profile figures, including political leaders, judicial executives, and notable figures from law enforcement, sports, and entertainment. With Governor James McGreevy, FBI LEEDA executives, and prominent advocates in attendance, the event underscored the urgency of criminal justice reform and reentry support.

A Penitent Thief delves deep into the personal journeys of individuals who have endured lengthy prison sentences. Through raw and emotional testimonies, the film sheds light on their struggles with addiction, societal reintegration, and the arduous path to redemption. The documentary’s impact is already being recognized nationally, with the FBI LEEDA inviting Director Harmatz to present his work at their national conference.

The evening began with an elegant red carpet welcome, offering attendees the chance to meet the director and other VIP guests, captured by award-winning photographer Ray Bailey. A rich musical lineup set the tone, featuring a mesmerizing saxophone performance by Matthew Richards, known for his appearance on The Kelly Clarkson Show, and a piano recital by the internationally acclaimed Mikhail Romanov.

The program officially commenced with a heartfelt welcome from the event’s M.C., Hugo, followed by a stirring rendition of the National Anthem by Layonne Holmes, a celebrated background singer for Bruce Springsteen and Bon Jovi. Rev. Anthony Hawthorne then led the audience in prayer, and Father Zachariah Presutti offered words of inspiration on behalf of the Archdiocese of New York. Jacques Battiste, Executive Director of FBI LEEDA, highlighted the film’s significance in criminal justice advocacy before Director Harmatz provided insight into his documentary’s powerful message.

The screening itself was a deeply moving experience. The audience was visibly engaged as the film unfolded, exposing the harsh realities of incarceration and the challenges of reentering society. The documentary does not just depict hardship—it highlights resilience and the unwavering human spirit. By weaving together stories of those seeking a second chance, A Penitent Thief presents a compelling argument for rehabilitation over punishment.

Following the screening, Governor James McGreevy delivered poignant remarks, reinforcing his commitment to criminal justice reform and reentry programs. His words resonated deeply with the audience, many of whom are actively engaged in efforts to reshape policies affecting formerly incarcerated individuals. The evening concluded with closing statements from Hugo, a recipient of the prestigious Congressional Award and the Four Chaplains Award, who left the audience with a lasting message of hope and change.

A Penitent Thief is more than just a documentary—it is a call to action. Its compelling storytelling and firsthand accounts make it a must-watch for anyone concerned about justice and rehabilitation. By providing a platform for voices too often unheard, the film challenges viewers to reconsider their perceptions of those entangled in the criminal justice system.

For those who missed this powerful screening, it is highly recommended to watch A Penitent Thief when it becomes publicly available. The documentary stands as a testament to the power of redemption and the collective responsibility we share in shaping a more just and compassionate society.